Garage Door Repair vs. Garage Door Replacement: How to Decide

Damaged garage door slightly off its hinges, indicating the need for replacement.

Tracker Door Systems Helps Kansas City Homeowners, No Matter Their Choice

You would never defer maintenance on your home’s heating and cooling system because you know what it could mean if you did: major breakdowns, expensive utility bills, pricey repair costs, and an uncomfortable home.

But many homeowners don’t notice the nuanced changes in how their garage door systems operate over the years. In fact, it’s easy to miss minor problems altogether until there’s a major issue.

Then, it’s time to make a decision: Do I repair my garage door system or replace it entirely? Keep reading for more information to guide your choice.

Will the Garage Door Repair Cost More Than a Replacement?

If your garage door, its moving parts, or your opener is severely damaged, the cost to repair them may outweigh the cost of a garage door replacement.

Garage door repairs can add up, especially if multiple moving parts are involved, or if your garage sustained storm damage, for example.

Compare the costs of repair to the costs of door system replacement. If your repair costs are approaching replacement costs, you may want to opt for the replacement.

Keep in mind that a new garage door enhances your home’s curb appeal. Many homeowners experience a 100% return on investment after garage door replacement, making it worth every penny spent.

Are You Due for a Garage Door Replacement?

If your garage door, its moving parts, and your opener are older, it may be time to replace them rather than repair them.

Garage doors are designed to last between 15 and 30 years, depending on how they’re used. Most door opener systems last up to 15 years. If yours are nearing the end of their useful lives, we recommend getting an estimate on a garage door replacement in Kansas City.

Keeping your old garage door and its aging equipment could affect your home’s value, especially if you plan to sell anytime soon. In fact, 70% of real estate agents agree that a new garage door helps a home sell faster.

Is Your Garage Door Warped or Structurally Compromised?

There are some instances when a garage door replacement is completely necessary and should not be considered optional. If your garage door is structurally damaged due to warping or if its panels are cracked or rusted out, it’s time for a replacement.

Damaged doors are unbalanced doors, which puts strain on your opener system. Damaged doors can also provide unrestricted access to your garage, which could encourage crimes of opportunity, such as theft or breaking and entering.

Are You Completing an Exterior Home Renovation?

If your garage door is in need of repairs, but you’re planning on a complete exterior renovation, including new siding and paint, you might want to consider garage door replacement as part of your remodel.

New garage doors improve curb appeal, and your old garage door may look out of place against a like-new home exterior.

Schedule garage door installation before your new siding and trim is put up, so that your exterior renovator can ensure everything matches perfectly.

What Does Your Professional Garage Door Repairman Think?

If you’re weighing the decision between garage door replacement and garage door repair, ask for professional advice. The garage door repairmen at Tracker Door Systems will never pressure you to buy new equipment.

Rather, our repair team will inform you of your options and tell you the truth about the condition of your garage door system. We will provide cost information on all your options and leave the decision to you. However, we are always happy to offer our professional opinion, which is informed by decades of experience and a dedication to making our customers happy.

Partner with Trusted Garage Door Installers Near You for Your Next Garage Door Purchase

With a current 5-star review average on Google and more than 20 years of experience serving homeowners in the Kansas City area, Tracker Door Systems, based in DeSoto, Kansas, is here to help you with your garage door replacement or repairs.

Our dependable and prepared technicians don’t work on commission, so you can trust them to tell you the truth about what your garage door and its system needs, whether that’s a repair, new equipment, or a complete replacement. They aren’t motivated by profit, but rather a sense of satisfaction in a job well done.

To schedule repairs or to learn more about garage door replacements, call Tracker Door Systems at (913) 585-3100.

Share:

More Posts

A two-story brick house with a snow-covered roof featuring three brown wood garage doors with windows. The driveway is partially covered in snow.

Garage Door Insulation: R-Value and Energy Efficiency

An insulated garage door can help regulate your garage’s temperature, lower energy costs, and improve comfort year-round. This guide explains R-value, U-factor, and insulation types so you can choose the best energy-efficient upgrade for your home. Ready to save on heating and cooling bills? Tracker Door Systems can help you find the perfect insulated garage door.

A two-car garage with wooden ENERGY STAR-certified doors on a light green home surrounded by trees, showcasing energy efficiency.

Energy Tax Credits for Garage Doors: Save Big in 2025

Upgrading to an ENERGY STAR-certified garage door can lower energy costs and qualify you for a federal tax credit of up to $500 annually. Through 2032, homeowners can claim 30% of the product cost while improving efficiency and curb appeal. This guide covers eligibility, savings, and how to maximize your tax benefits.

A modern two-story house with gray siding and brown accents. The home features a two-car garage with a white garage door, a paved driveway, and a landscaped front yard.

5 Ways to Make Your Garage Door Quieter

A noisy garage door can be frustrating, but there are simple ways to make it quieter. This guide covers easy fixes like lubricating moving parts, tightening loose bolts, and checking your garage door opener. If the noise persists, it may be time for professional maintenance or even a new, quieter system. Tracker Door Systems can help you find the right solution.

A garage technician in red overalls and gloves adjusts a cable on a white sectional garage door during an installation.

Exterior Door Tax Credit: Save Money with an ENERGY STAR Garage Door

Upgrading to an ENERGY STAR-certified garage door can save you money and improve energy efficiency. Under the Inflation Reduction Act, homeowners can claim up to 30% of the cost of an eligible garage door as a federal tax credit—saving up to $500 annually. This guide covers eligibility, benefits, and how to claim your savings.

Send Us A Message